Written
For
The
Australian
-
Why
government
help
may
be
setting
up
first-home
buyers
for
failure

Could someone earning $500,000 a year really need government help to buy a house? From October 1, that's exactly what will be possible under the expanded Home Guarantee Scheme — and I think we need to pump the brakes.

The scheme lets first-home buyers into the market with just a 5 per cent deposit, or 2 per cent if you're a single parent. From next month, the annual caps on places are gone, income caps are being scrapped entirely, and the maximum purchase price in Sydney jumps from $900,000 to $1.5m. Combine it with state-based stamp duty exemptions and a single parent in NSW can buy an $800,000 property with just $16,000 down plus legals. That's frighteningly little skin in the game.

Here's my issue. Banks don't demand a 20 per cent deposit purely to protect themselves in a default. They ask for it because saving that amount proves financial discipline — the same discipline you need to service a mortgage for 30 years. Strip that filter away and you're inviting risk into the system. If someone on half a million dollars a year can't save a deposit, that's a red flag, not a reason for taxpayer support.

I get it — a 20 per cent deposit in Sydney is out of reach for most first-timers. But 10 per cent strikes a fair balance. It's achievable with genuine effort and it signals commitment.

My concern is timing. Rates are falling, prices are rising, and demand is about to surge with no supply response. Fast-forward two years — if rates lift, unemployment ticks up and prices soften, wafer-thin-deposit buyers could quickly find themselves in negative equity. History backs this up: LMI claims in the five years to around 2020 hit $1.2bn versus under $300m in the past five.

If it turns, it won't just be borrowers hurting. Taxpayers will foot the bill.

James Gerrard - Why government help may be setting up first-home buyers for failure

Read the Full Article
Related Content
When a simple bank account isn’t so simple.

Read

James on ABC News Breakfast - How to find your slice of the $25Bn in lost money

Read

James on ABC News Breakfast - Why ANZ shares fell after announcing billions in profit

Read

Do you know what you’re paying for? Insurance premiums in your super

Read

Wanting to enter the property market but can’t afford properties where you want to live? Why not Rentvest?

Read